Measuring Molasses with a WORM

A rigid sensor couldn’t measure temperature accurately in a conventional thermowell, but a custom thermowell and a WORM RTD flexible sensor measure the molasses perfectly.

A world-class agricultural cooperative specializing in the production of sugar and related agri-products and the largest beet sugar producer in the United States uses innovative farming practices and low-cost production methods to keep its leadership position in the industry.

Making Molasses

The company’s beet sugar processing takes place in specially designed processing facilities. At each factory, sugar beets are washed and sliced into thin strips called cossettes. The cossettes go through a large tank called a diffuser where raw sugar juice is extracted. The cossettes are gently lifted from the bottom to the top of the diffuser as hot water washes over them absorbing the sugar. After the sugar-laden raw juice is drawn off, the beet pulp is left behind. This pulp is processed separately and formed into pellets for livestock feed and other products.

The raw juice is mingled with milk of lime and carbon dioxide gas in carbonation tanks. The carbon dioxide bubbles through the mixture forming calcium carbonate. The non-sugar particles attach themselves to the calcium carbonate and settle to the bottom of the tanks.

The juice is then filtered, leaving a golden light brown clarified thin juice. This juice is boiled under vacuum where much of the water is evaporated, forming a thicker juice similar to pancake syrup. After a second filtration to ensure that all non-sugar materials are removed, the juice goes to the boiling pans. Once again the juice is boiled under vacuum and crystals begin to form. The resulting sugar crystal and syrup mix is called massecuite.

The massecuite is then sent to centrifuges for separation. By spinning rapidly in a perforated cylindrical basket, the molasses syrup is thrown off through the screen holes. Non-sugars that were not removed earlier in the process finally come out in the molasses.

Measuring Molasses Temperature

Measuring the molasses temperature at the centrifuge was always a problem. Process engineers originally used a standard thermowell with a rigid sensor. The thermowell was screwed into a six-inch pipe. The molasses only runs about 1 1/2-in. deep in the bottom of the horizontal pipe, and quite a bit of steam fills the rest of the pipe. With just the tip of the thermowell immersed in the molasses and the rest of the thermowell surrounded by steam, it was not very responsive to a change in the molasses temperature.

Also, because the thermowell was exposed to the steam, the thermowell got hot, heated the stainless steel rigid sensor contained within, and essentially conducted the steam’s temperature down the probe to the sensor. Essentially they were measuring the steam temperature more than the molasses temperature.

To solve the problem, Moore Industries’ application engineers fabricated a custom thermowell out of 3/8-in. stainless steel tubing (Figure 1) and bent the end in a gentle radius. The rigid RTD was replaced with the Moore Industries’ WORM® RTD sensor and inserted into the thermowell, past the bend, to the very end of the tubing, where it lays right in the molasses (inside the thermowell). A spring keeps the end of the WORM sensor snugly in place. Because the WORM sensor is only one inch long, steam heating the stainless steel tubing has no effect on the temperature reading.

Figure 3: This six-inch pipe carries molasses from a centrifuge to a storage vessel. A custom thermowell (at the center) was made from 3/8-in. stainless tubing to house a WORM flexible RTD sensor.

A Parker CPI compression fitting was used to connect the 3/8-in. tube to a 1/2-in. NPT pipe screwed into a conduit body (Figure 2). A retainer clip that comes with the WORM was used to hold the RTD and spring in place. The retainer clip is visible in Figure 2, at the bottom of the conduit (the cover plate was removed for this photo).

Figure 2: The stainless steel tubing connects to conduit. The retainer clip for the WORM sensor is visible at the bottom of the conduit.

Figure 3 is a shot from above, through the round access hole in the pipe, showing the end of the custom thermowell. When this photo was taken, the system was in a cleaning cycle so there is no steam and just a little water in the pipe, making the end visible. Normally, it would be submerged in 1-1/2 in. of molasses.

Figure 3. Looking down through the access hole in the pipe, this photo shows the end of the custom thermowell, laying horizontal. During normal operations, the end of the thermowell is submerged in 1-1/2 inches of molasses.

Since the custom thermowell and the WORM have been installed, temperature measurement is much more accurate, and the sensor responds quickly to changes in temperature. This allows more precise control of the water and steam used in the centrifuge, allowing better control of the separation of molasses and sugar, which means more sugar in the bag and less lost to molasses.

The process engineers at the plant also learned, after this project was complete, that Moore Industries offers a WORM NOSE kit, which makes it much easier to fabricate a custom thermowell. The WORM NOSE seals the end of the tubing and provides a snug fit for the WORM sensor. The kit includes a bracket for connecting the tubing to conduit or a pipe wall.

This article is published by

Since 1968, Moore Industries has been proudly serving process manufacturing businesses and fortune 500 companies in oil, gas, mining, chemical, power generation, water/waste water treatment, pharmaceutical, food, beverage, Mr Mooreconsumer packaged goods, semiconductor, and biotechnology industries. Moore Industries was founded by Leonard W. Moore with ...

Moore Industries-International, Inc.